Indy Card Exchange is an Official PSA Authorized Dealer. What that means is you can submit cards to us for grading, we then send your cards along with other customers in a group order to PSA, and they then can be picked up back at our shop when they are completed and shipped back to us from PSA. Customers choose to submit through us as it saves money on shipping and insurance versus sending them in yourself.
We only accept in-store submissions and cannot take mail-in submissions at this time due to demand.
If you are interested in submitting cards through the shop, please see our grading form below for the necessary information on available service levels, estimated turnaround times, cost per card, and what we ask of you the customer to agree to. Please print and complete your grading form(s) before bringing your cards to the shop. You must do a separate form for each grading level you are submitting at. So if you are submitting cards for two different bulk level services, you need to complete two separate forms.
As PSA requires, we ask that cards be submitted in grading submission semi-ridges. If you do not have any, we have those available for purchase at the shop. Thick cards (130pt & above) can be submitted in top loaders or one-touch magnetic holders.
We are happy to help you review your cards before sending if you want a second opinion, but if you have more than a handful to review, please email us to set up an appointment to look them over as we may not have the time during normal shop hours to accommodate everyone.
Orders are sent once per month. Please check out the events calendar to see when our next submission is being sent out. You will be contacted through email once your order has been completed by PSA and has arrived back at the shop. If you have any additional questions on the grading process, please contact the shop.
A video explaining how to full out the submission form is on the right of this page!