We. Know. Cards.
Welcome to Indy Card Exchange!  We are your one stop, full-service local card shop serving Indianapolis, Central Indiana, and the Midwest.  We specialize in vintage and new singles, packs, wax boxes, card supplies, autographed memorabilia, grading, and online breaks.

We carry all major sports and some non-sport including baseball (MLB), basketball (NBA), football (NFL), hockey (NHL), Soccer (MLS, UEFA, EPL), UFC, WWE, Star Wars, Marvel, and more from all the major card manufacturers including Panini, Topps, Upper Deck, and Leaf.
Make sure to come by the shop or contact us for all of your sports card hobby needs!
Shop Update:
Our temporary hours are Tuesday through Saturday from 11am to 5pm and we are operating more like a carry out style of business again. Masks and social distancing are required in the shop at this time. We also require use of hand sanitizer when entering the shop, either your own or from the bottle provided by the shop.  We ask customers to keep their stay to 10-15 minutes. No single card boxes or commons boxes are out at this time. Please see the Beckett & PSA pages under the "grading" tab for our new grading process. We will only be looking at collections to purchase by appointment at this time. Please use the "Contact Us" tab at the top of the page to get in touch with us to set up a time.
Sign-up for our weekly e-newsletter to receive updates on new products, special promotions, and upcoming events.
Event Calendar
PSA Grading Submission Deadline Date
Saturday, December 5, 2020
12pm to 5pm
The deadline to submit cards for our next PSA grading submission is by the end of day (5pm) on this day. For more information on PSA Grading, please check out...
Memorabilia Framing Submission Deadline Date
Saturday, December 12, 2020
10am to 5pm
The deadline to turn in items for our next memorabilia framing order to our framing partner is end of day (5pm) on this day. Items that you may want to...
J&J All Star Sports Card Show
Saturday, December 19, 2020
8am to 2pm
Monthly card show at the American Legion #470 in Fishers, IN. For more information please go to www.jjallstarsportscards.com.